Skip to content
  • Shop Candy
    • All Candy
    • Candy Under $1
    • Back In Stock Candy
    • Gum
    • Halal Sweets
    • International Candy
    • Lollipops
    • Nostalgic Candy
    • Popping Candy
    • Sour Candy
  • All Gummy Mixes
    • Gummy Mixes
    • Custom Gummy Mixes
  • Shop Snacks
    • New Arrivals
    • Anime Snacks
    • Back in Stock
    • Best Sellers
    • Breakfast and Snack Foods
    • Cookies and Cakes
    • Character Snacks
    • Chips
    • Chocolate
    • Drinks
    • Jelly Fruit
    • Ramen & Seasoning
  • Mystery Bundles/Boxes
    • Candy Bags/Boxes
    • Snack Bundles
  • Shop Collectibles
    • Stickers
    • Japanese Capsule Toys
  • Grow on TikTok
  • Customer Service
    • Track Order
    • Send us a Message
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Account
BUTWAITIMHUNGRY
Cart
  • Shop Candy
      Shop Candy
    • All
    • All Candy
    • Candy Under $1
    • Back In Stock Candy
    • Gum
    • Halal Sweets
    • International Candy
    • Lollipops
    • Nostalgic Candy
    • Popping Candy
    • Sour Candy
    • Llama Doo Candy Dispenser
      Llama Doo Candy Dispenser
      Regular price $4
      View
      Stick Candy | Peaches and Cream
      Stick Candy | Peaches and Cream
      Regular price $0.50
      View
      Stick Candy | Sour Strawberry
      Stick Candy | Sour Strawberry
      Regular price $0.50
      View
  • All Gummy Mixes
      All Gummy Mixes
    • All
    • Gummy Mixes
    • Custom Gummy Mixes
    • Tootsie Frooties Mix
      Tootsie Frooties Mix
      From $1.25
      View
      Sour Patch Kids Peach | 4 oz.
      Sour Patch Kids Peach | 4 oz.
      Regular price $4
      View
      Peach Rings | 4 oz.
      Peach Rings | 4 oz.
      Regular price $4
      View
      Gummy Worms [Sugar-Free] | 4 oz.
      Gummy Worms [Sugar-Free] | 4 oz.
      Regular price $4
      View
  • Shop Snacks
    • New Arrivals
    • Anime Snacks
    • Back in Stock
    • Best Sellers
    • Breakfast and Snack Foods
    • Cookies and Cakes
    • Character Snacks
    • Chips
    • Chocolate
    • Drinks
    • Jelly Fruit
    • Ramen & Seasoning
  • Mystery Bundles/Boxes
      Mystery Bundles/Boxes
    • All
    • Candy Bags/Boxes
    • Snack Bundles
    • " Happy Birthday " Mystery Candy Box
      " Happy Birthday " Mystery Candy Box
      Regular price $18
      View
      Gummy Candy Bundle | Mini
      Gummy Candy Bundle | Mini
      Regular price $5.95
      View
      Lollipop Mystery Box
      Lollipop Mystery Box
      Regular price $12
      View
      "Gummy " Mystery Candy Box
      "Gummy " Mystery Candy Box
      From $16
      View
  • Shop Collectibles
      Shop Collectibles
    • All
    • Stickers
    • Japanese Capsule Toys
    • Pride Mystery Sticker Pack
      Pride Mystery Sticker Pack
      From $3
      View
      Demon Slayer Bandaids w/ Case
      Demon Slayer Bandaids w/ Case
      Regular price $12
      View
      Jujutsu Kaisen | Mini Figure - Japan
      Jujutsu Kaisen | Mini Figure - Japan
      Sold Out
      View
      Demon Slayer | Mini Plush - Japan
      Demon Slayer | Mini Plush - Japan
      Sold Out
      View
  • Grow on TikTok
  • Customer Service
    • Track Order
    • Send us a Message
    • Frequently Asked Questions
Account
Item added to cart. View cart and check out.
Happy Holidays! | Follow @BUTWAITIMHUNGRYTOO on social media!

Nostalgic Candy

Browse our selection of Nostalgic Candy

Rewind the clock to " The Good Ol' Days "
Sour Power Belts | Blue Raspberry
Sour Power Belts | Blue Raspberry
Sold Out
View
Sour Power Belts | Strawberry
Sour Power Belts | Strawberry
Regular price $0.25
View
Sour Power | Quattro Belts
Sour Power | Quattro Belts
Sold Out
View
Stick Candy | Sour Blue Raspberry
Stick Candy | Sour Blue Raspberry
Regular price $0.50
View
Candy " Cigarettes " | Bubble Gum
Candy " Cigarettes " | Bubble Gum
Regular price $1.75
View
Sour Power Belts | Green Apple
Sour Power Belts | Green Apple
Regular price $0.25
View
E-Frutti | Gummi Pizza
E-Frutti | Gummi Pizza
Regular price $0.60
View
Sour Power Belts | Watermelon
Sour Power Belts | Watermelon
Regular price $0.25
View
E-Frutti | Mini Burgers
E-Frutti | Mini Burgers
Regular price $0.25
View
Tootsie Frooties | Blue Raspberry
Tootsie Frooties | Blue Raspberry
Regular price $0.10
View
Tootsie Frooties | Strawberry Lemonade
Tootsie Frooties | Strawberry Lemonade
Regular price $0.10
View
E-Frutti | Hot Dog
E-Frutti | Hot Dog
Sold Out
View
Tootsie Frooties | Watermelon
Tootsie Frooties | Watermelon
Regular price $0.10
View
Pop Rocks | Cotton Candy
Pop Rocks | Cotton Candy
Sold Out
View
E-Frutti | Sour Mini Burgers
E-Frutti | Sour Mini Burgers
Sold Out
View
Now & Later | Blue Raspberry
Now & Later | Blue Raspberry
Sold Out
View
Fruit Gushers
Fruit Gushers
Sold Out
View
Airheads | Blue Raspberry
Airheads | Blue Raspberry
Regular price $0.40
View
Tootsie Frooties | Fruit Punch
Tootsie Frooties | Fruit Punch
Sold Out
View
Fruit Slice Pops | Peach
Fruit Slice Pops | Peach
Regular price $0.50
View
1 2 3 … 5 →

Information

  • Contact Us
  • Shipping Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
© 2023, BUTWAITIMHUNGRY. Powered by Shopify
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
  • Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device